Ideation Communities Report

Executive Summary

We analyzed 13 ideation communities listed on Hive Index to understand where people gather, what these groups offer, and which communities attract the most interest.

The big picture: In this smaller sample, ideation listings cluster on Independent Platforms, while a few large groups pull member averages up.

Source: Hive Index community database · Updated periodically

Communities
13
Platforms
5
Avg members
170K
Median members
2K

Where Ideation Communities Are Hosted

  • Independent Platforms: 7 communities (54%)
  • LinkedIn: 2 communities (15%)
  • Reddit: 2 communities (15%)
  • Skool: 1 communities (8%)
  • Discord: 1 communities (8%)
  • Independent Platforms
    Independent Platforms
    7(54%)
  • LinkedIn
    2(15%)
  • Reddit
    2(15%)
  • Skool
    1(8%)
  • Discord
    1(8%)

Format mix

  • Forum / feed-based
    9(69%)
  • Other platforms
    2(15%)
  • Private membership
    1(8%)
  • Chat communities
    1(8%)

Most listings are forum / feed-based (69%).

Independent Platforms leads (54% of listings).

Audience Size & Access

Community size

  • Tiny: 0 communities (0%)
  • Small: 0 communities (0%)
  • Medium: 2 communities (15%)
  • Large: 4 communities (31%)
  • Huge: 0 communities (0%)
  • Massive: 2 communities (15%)
  • Gigantic: 0 communities (0%)
  • Tiny
    <20 members
    0(0%)
  • Small
    20-100 members
    0(0%)
  • Medium
    100-1,000 members
    2(15%)
  • Large
    1,000-10,000 members
    4(31%)
  • Huge
    10,000-100,000 members
    0(0%)
  • Massive
    100,000-1M members
    2(15%)
  • Gigantic
    1M+ members
    0(0%)

5 communities have unknown member counts.

Free vs paid

  • Free to join: 10 communities (77%)
  • Paid or apply-to-join: 3 communities (23%)

The average is much higher than the median (170K vs 2K), which usually means a few large groups are pulling the average up.

How Ideation Differs From Other Categories

Ideation is smaller than typical Hive Index topics.

MetricIdeationHive Index average
Free to join77%84%
Median members2K25K
Average members170K662K
Paid or apply-to-join23%16%
Live chat15%41%
Discord share8%18%

Feature Mix

Common features appear in at least 15% of listings.

Common Features

  • Forum: 13 communities (100%)
  • Online/Offline Events: 7 communities (54%)
  • Courses: 4 communities (31%)
  • Job Board: 3 communities (23%)
  • Member Perks: 3 communities (23%)
  • Newsletter: 3 communities (23%)
  • Pairing: 3 communities (23%)
  • Live Chat: 2 communities (15%)
  • Forum
    100%
  • Online/Offline Events
    54%
  • Courses
    31%
  • Job Board
    23%
  • Member Perks
    23%
  • Newsletter
    23%
  • Pairing
    23%
  • Live Chat
    15%

Niche Features

  • Requires Application: 1 communities (8%)
  • Tools: 1 communities (8%)
  • Requires Application
    8%
  • Tools
    8%

Forum appears on 100% of listings.

What Visitors Click

Outbound clicks / mo
24

Platform supply vs. clicks

PlatformCommunitiesShare of communitiesOutbound clicksShare of clicks
Independent Platforms754%
417%
LinkedIn215%
417%
Reddit215%
521%
Discord18%
1146%

Share is calculated within this topic.

Discord gets 46% of clicks but only 8% of listings, so visitors click it more than you'd expect from supply alone.

Most-clicked formats

  • Chat communities
    11(46%)
  • Forum / feed-based
    9(38%)
  • Other platforms
    4(17%)

Most-clicked features

  • Forum
    24(100%)
  • Courses
    15(63%)
  • Live Chat
    15(63%)
  • Newsletter
    15(63%)
  • Online/Offline Events
    15(63%)
  • Member Perks
    11(46%)

Most-clicked size ranges

  • Large
    15(63%)
  • Massive
    5(21%)
  • Medium
    4(17%)

Top-clicked listings

  • Internet Pipes
    11(46%)
  • FoundersList
    4(17%)
  • Global Alliance of Startup Co-Founders
    4(17%)

Most clicks go to chat communities and forum / feed-based communities.

Community Quality & Ratings

Only 1 community has ratings so far, so read this as a small sample.

5.0 average rating across 1 community.

Methodology & FAQ

Methodology

This report uses communities in the Hive Index database tagged as Ideation. We exclude removed or suppressed listings. Member counts, traffic, features, reviews, and ratings may vary by source and are updated periodically.

  • •We only have a handful of listings so far, so treat these numbers as directional.

FAQ