What are true crime communities?

Communities for fans of true crime podcasts, documentaries, books, and ongoing cases. Reddit dominates this space with massive subreddits covering cold cases, citizen detective work, and specific cases that have captured public attention. Discord servers offer real-time discussion, watch parties, and deeper dives into particular investigations.

Where do most true crime communities live?

Independent Platforms is the most common platform in this report (57% of 14 listings).

Are most of these communities free?

71% are free to join. The rest require payment, an application, or both.

How big is a typical true crime community?

Among listings with public size data, the average is 931K members and the median is 246K. The median is usually the better signal for a typical group because a few large ones inflate the average.

What do these communities usually include?

Forum is the most common (79%). Others that show up often include live chat, online/offline events, and paid community.

How does Hive Index collect this data?

Listings are submitted by community builders and researchers, reviewed for relevance, and updated with platform, feature, member, review, and traffic data where available.

Where can I see the full list?

The full directory is on Hive Index's True Crime topic page, where you can filter by platform, size, features, and more.

True Crime Communities Report: Stats, Platforms, Trends...

Executive Summary

We analyzed 14 true crime communities listed on Hive Index to understand where people gather, what these groups offer, and which communities attract the most interest.

The big picture: In this smaller sample, true crime listings cluster on Independent Platforms, while a few large groups pull member averages up.

Source: Hive Index community database · Updated periodically

Browse all True Crime communities Know a community we're missing? Add it

Communities: 14
Platforms: 3
Avg members: 931K
Median members: 246K

Where True Crime Communities Are Hosted

Independent Platforms
8(57%)
Reddit
4(29%)
Discord
2(14%)

Format mix

Forum / feed-based
12(86%)
Chat communities
2(14%)

Most listings are forum / feed-based (86%).

Independent Platforms leads (57% of listings).

Audience Size & Access

Community size

Tiny
<20 members
0(0%)
Small
20-100 members
0(0%)
Medium
100-1,000 members
1(7%)
Large
1,000-10,000 members
1(7%)
Huge
10,000-100,000 members
0(0%)
Massive
100,000-1M members
4(29%)
Gigantic
1M+ members
1(7%)

7 communities have unknown member counts.

Free vs paid

The average is much higher than the median (931K vs 246K), which usually means a few large groups are pulling the average up.

How True Crime Differs From Other Categories

True Crime is less free-to-join, larger, and more paid or gated, compared with typical Hive Index topics.

Metric	True Crime	Hive Index average
Free to join	71%	84%
Median members	246K	25K
Average members	931K	672K
Paid or apply-to-join	29%	16%
Live chat	29%	41%
Discord share	14%	18%

Feature Mix

Common features appear in at least 15% of listings.

Common Features

Forum
79%
Live Chat
29%
Online/Offline Events
29%
Paid Community
29%

Niche Features

Courses
7%
Newsletter
7%
Requires Application
7%

Forum appears on 79% of listings.

What Visitors Click

Outbound clicks / mo: 178

Platform supply vs. clicks

Platform	Communities	Share of communities	Outbound clicks	Share of clicks
Independent Platforms	8	57%	66	37%
Reddit	4	29%	14	8%
Discord	2	14%	98	55%

Share is calculated within this topic.

Discord gets 55% of clicks but only 14% of listings, so visitors click it more than you'd expect from supply alone.

Most-clicked formats

Chat communities
98(55%)
Forum / feed-based
80(45%)

Most-clicked features

Live Chat
105(59%)
Forum
78(44%)
Online/Offline Events
16(9%)
Paid Community
15(8%)
Courses
7(4%)
Newsletter
7(4%)

Most-clicked size ranges

Large
95(53%)
Massive
35(20%)
Gigantic
8(4%)
Medium
3(2%)

Top-clicked listings

Lurkwell
95(53%)
Websleuths
29(16%)
True Crime Obsessed
14(8%)

Most clicks go to chat communities and forum / feed-based communities.

Trends

Founded year

1995

1999

2019

11 communities have no founding year on file.

Most listed groups were founded around 1995.

Methodology & FAQ

Methodology

This report uses communities in the Hive Index database tagged as True Crime. We exclude removed or suppressed listings. Member counts, traffic, features, reviews, and ratings may vary by source and are updated periodically.

•We only have a handful of listings so far, so treat these numbers as directional.

FAQ

: Communities for fans of true crime podcasts, documentaries, books, and ongoing cases. Reddit dominates this space with massive subreddits covering cold cases, citizen detective work, and specific cases that have captured public attention. Discord servers offer real-time discussion, watch parties, and deeper dives into particular investigations.
: Independent Platforms is the most common platform in this report (57% of 14 listings).
: 71% are free to join. The rest require payment, an application, or both.
: Among listings with public size data, the average is 931K members and the median is 246K. The median is usually the better signal for a typical group because a few large ones inflate the average.
: Forum is the most common (79%). Others that show up often include live chat, online/offline events, and paid community.
: Listings are submitted by community builders and researchers, reviewed for relevance, and updated with platform, feature, member, review, and traffic data where available.
: The full directory is on Hive Index's True Crime topic page, where you can filter by platform, size, features, and more.

Keep exploring

Browse

All True Crime communities

Related reports